IDEAS FOR RYZOM

Daomei, yes this will indeed create some pvp but there's no pve challenge sacrificed, boss will remain at the same place with same power and weakness.


off topic : Talking about new region is an insult to all players, you know it'll took years.

Azram, of course that destroys a PvE opportunity, as those not willing to do PvP cannot participate and are deprived their chance to do a boss fight.

And there is no lack of PvP opportunities, rather a lack of will to participate in PvP. There have been no (or extremely few) OP fights since months. I think there was a PvP contest inside the Atys games, I do not know exactly how well it was attended, but not overwhelmingly to my impression. And there has not been any player organized PvP tournament for a long time. I recall one where I participated in donating prizes (mainly for F2P), but that is long ago.

As long as the existing opportunities for PvP are not used I fail to see much reason to create new ones, and definitely not on cost of those who do not practise PvP.

I won't interfere into descriptions about a boss fight I did not witness, though the "accidential appearance" of kitins when a team was fighting cratchakin's minibosses (kitins are a good way distant from cratchakin's spawn), and the subsequent takeover of the boss kill by the perpetrators, if I understood that correctly, simply stinks. It may have been accidential, anyway, and all behaviour conforming to the rules. Who knows.

But it shows quite well what is to expect when all boss fights would become PvP challenges. All practices, including the filthiest ones like dragging agro, attacking tagged teammates to render them unhealable for non tagged ones and other questionable methods would become perfectly legal, with boss hunts degrading into brawls and sneaky assaults excluding everybody who does not practise PvP, or at least prefers fair fights. It would also destroy opportunities for experienced players to attack high level bosses in small teams, as numerically superior brawlers would overwhelm them in their already risky fight.

So this confirms my conviction that changing boss hunts into PvP fights is a bad idea, broken by design. On Leanon, we had a convention (sort of community agreement, not completely binding but followed by almost everybody) that a boss "belonged" to that one who detected it, granting the right to form a team, for 20-30 minutes approximately. That allowed even young players, if sufficiently curious and daring, to spot bosses, and to participate in the fight. I loved that.

Yeah... you won't but you did.
I'm sure of what I saw, they was in good health when I arrive, we waited then we had to kill a cuttler this was who didn't stay alive more than 20secondes, few minutes after the rangers died.
That's not our fault if they don't heal themself.

"attacking tagged teammates to render them unhealable for non tagged ones"
You are wrong.

"and other questionable methods would become perfectly legal"
RCC > III. Rules > 5 - PvP.

"broken by design"
Open your mind just a little.