English

I'm still pretty much a noob, wandering around Silan with the highest lvl of 74. so I have not witnessed the "old" economy; I however have some thoughts re economy in general :)

The market lacks transparency, and price discovery process is hard - I'd probably need to put at least 15 times 100 units of fine Koorin oil on the market at different prices just to find out what the market clearing price is. Rinse and repeat for every material out there, and I'd not be finished before moving on to better mats and starting it all over again.

Some sort of latest deals tracker could be useful, at least to an extent.

Another option would be an automatic discounting system - e.g., if an item is not sold in 24 h, then 10% of markup gets cut off; traders in high-end stuff where the market is less liquid would probably object to this, however.

Haruto: The Market on Silan is somewhat simple-minded, base prices differ between 1 (basic) and 3 (fine) per unit. That is acceptable for simple q10 stuff, but nonsense for q45 dig mats from the jungle (at least it was so when I and my alt leaved Silan a couple of weeks ago). As to the old economy, base price was roughly 100fold, similar on the continent where you got about 1300 per unit q250 compared t0 44 today.

If you want to resell, put 1000% (10fold) on normal stuff such as q20+ dig and chase mat, 2000 on fine, and 5000+ on boss (dominant ocyx, cray, kirosta) mat. You will see all being resold.

ok, this is stupid, there is nothing to do on Atys anymore except dapper missions and socializing. There is no sup bosses to hunt (only extremely rarely now), there is no sup mats to find, (Only extremely rarely now! and only for 5 seconds), there is totally no reason whatsoever to go to Nexus now, no sup mats there anymore or bosses it seems. Might as well delete it off the map. There is really no reason to own an OP either! Whoever came up with these 'new' ideas for Ryzom is ruining it!

I could not disagree more. Do the math: more players, less limited material per player. That simple. Unsure about Nexus, admittedly, as there seems to be a bug concerning higher materials. File a ticket.

I widely stopped running for dappers, doing a crafting mission here and then. I am back to level grinding, team fights against NPC bosses, still about to restore my occupations' skills (some weeks to go til I have all at grade 6), looking for ways to master more skills. I am happy that finding or creating plodi teams became that easy. I am much appreciating the larger community.

Mind: before I had my apt and my sister Diwu's apt full of boss mats above q 220, a GH (Diwu's) full of exc and sup mat below q210, a backup GH (alt player) still full of exc and sup up to q250, and nearly 3 billion dapper cash, on a dying server (I am not an old player, I finished my 2nd year on Atys begin of December). I may as well mention about 300 of each category of q189 divine potions, and hundreds of q60 and q70 occupation products of any kind. I do not regret a second what we have lost, and I love the new world.

Soon I shall proudly own 50m dapper - only few days to go. That is for the achievements, afterwards, I shall care few about getting dappers, maintaining my fortune, but in no way striving to become a billionaire again. I may intensify my search for sup in the PR, so far I have only few. I admit that I dislike the new way mats are distributed in the PR as do many. Yet one can arrange with and has to do.

I fail to see that the devs could and should multiply top materials only because the server is populated, now. I live not badly with my exc equipment. Limitations in equip are challenging for abilities as a fighter.

As to OP, I do not know to which extent the initial problems with drill and yield have been settled. The owners of OPs might comment on. Once the trade with high level and OP mat will be revived, we shall see. Possibly the devs should assess the ratio of OP mat and player base and adjust production if necessary.

But in no way I could corroborate that the game is being ruined. On contrary, it is more interesting and challenging than it was before. Kindly concentrate criticism on real drawbacks. There may be some, no doubt. Thank you.

well then you are brilliant then Daomei, i have finally got my packers, apt and mount, and finally 1 mill dappers, perhaps you are smarter at playing the game than me.
I admit, i am neutral which makes the game harder for me to get around, but thats not really the problem. I have not even begun to restart my 3 occs i had at grade 6 yet. i am still trying get enough dappers to feel comfortable. Then i want to start contributing to our GH if i can.
I still stand by what i said in my earlier statement.

simple, they want missionsto be played, we want them to pay out, make more missions that pay out, who cares if there are a bunch of toon's with billion's (i want to be one some day) i like to grind the game a little bit in many ways, let's have a way to grind dappers, make a mission that pays out good without restriction, make it take a little bit to do, say collect a total of 50 mat's, make them from different things, keep it simple, lower level, and give like 15,000 dappers. then it's still mission based but provides good dappers to anyone, high or low level, and everyone can stop going on about dappers, they're there if anyone wants to make them, and if you don't want to make them or don't like it, then don't, but the high lvl crafters could finally sell at higher prices and get paid for the goods they can craft by the lower less evolved toons. really, it's a game, give them away, who does it really hurt, and with a market tht's more dapper free, we have a world where people are happier and play more.

I doubt that I am much smarter, I got many hints how to optimize my gameplay from other players. Much also depends on the region, desert seems to be the easiest to me, my luck as that has ever been my homeland.

Yet one should be able to progress faster, even as an independent. neutral player. We neutrals, especially those without a guild, have to work harder, indeed. But it should not be that hard. Drop me a message about your problems

lol nae why did you not tell your fellow HO :P

truthfully it was very annoying and almost stressful at first not having enough to even TP easily to res dead homins but there is a great bias toward high level crafting

lets be frank - some people do not like digging and hence they wont craft anyway, for these players they will suffer greatly even with the forum post about how to do the other types of missions, the rewards are bad and it does not really train skills as much

i hated it at first but i picked one craft that most overseers ask for (shields, but jewels are always there too it seems) dug crafted, got high enough now to the point where when i need some i can do one or two high level missions and be content. there is almost nothing to buy (this is changing thankfully, players are using the sell-to-others feature more now)

i have found that if you try NOT to think about missions and just see them as a one-off sort of nuisance instead of a real addition to gameplay (they are NOT a real addition says i... they may force you to dig and craft and get levels and it may be beneficial to you to say this is a "motivation" but it is still forced, by the current system) then one can concentrate on perhaps other grinding or relations, or even the odd boss or two (personally i am dont subscribe to the boss or sup mat "must have" way of life on atys, so i cant imagine what it must be like having less to go around, with bugs to boot)

iirc your craft is higher than mine in some branches :P

sup and boss mats are supposed to be rare, i have to agree with daomei on this. perhaps the frequency of regeneration of each could be boosted somewhat, to satisfy the player populace who enjoy these things but rare does not necessarily mean impossible, if you consider that the new server has only been around a few months, in 8 more years everyone will be fully decked out anyway, the economy is going back to what it was, some homins have what they need and are now accumulating surplus dappers because there is nothing substantial for dapper sink besides perhaps OPs

a big part of the perceived issue is that many players are used to having sup boss npc related items and lots of extra cash from before the merge, i do not know what it feels like to have these things since i am still very new, so i cant empathise. there are some people who have quit but if they return in some months or years it is likely at that time that items mats and dappers would be alot easier to get after the server settles in, until they invent something to spend them on dappers are still fairly useless, once you have your meks apt gh tp money, donation money... then thats it besides ops

when you hit your first 10m you'll feel comfortable enough, i guarantee it

at that point THEN you can say, okay there isn't that much to do because there is not that much new content, it does seem to be appearing slowly. new horizons was a great change for neutrals especially and low levels, this is still an important part of the player base, even if some people are "cheating" for the new horizons dapper rewards with occs now, the honest players do benefit

pretty soon when everyone has surplus prices will either go up from players selling good gear, or more gifting will occur because of surplus and no need for dappers OR my preferred hope - both will happen. personally i enjoy gifting as much as shopping, i have received alot of hateful comments about being evil for supporting market economy but i think this is just one choice of many which does not intrude on the choice of gifting

we will just have to hope that bugs are fixed soon and that new content is on the way, and perhaps some alternative ways to make dappers, more choices never hurt. more choices means more players who play differently. atys has a fairly high tolerance for different playstyles but i have also been told that people who hate digging shouldnt be on here- i have to disagree, you should not have to dig if you don't want to. in fact. no one really has to it is just that it is more difficult to get by. and for anyone saying that dappers be abolished entirely, for there are some of you out there, i really do not know what to say. systems exist, what we make of them is up to us, let's find some ways to make the experience a good one

take advantage of dapper missions, use them as a reason to level dig and craft
take advantage of digging even if you hate it, see it as a way to get the most out of your stay on atys
take advantage of new horizons use them as a reason to see new lands
take advantage of the sell-to-others people will buy your items i do it all day, if it is a good item

if lack of bosses and sups starts driving you crazy either maybe go do something else or and get by on exe or choice gear till later. choice gear can be fantastic for grinding =/ but so many seem not to think so and this is again, because so many are used to having better pre-merge.

and. if you cant find something to do that you enjoy, perhaps think of something you might like to see and either suggest it or attempt to implement it. at the core of it i do believe that some people have already "done it all" and are trying hard to "get back" what they had before, and are lacking high level new content to keep them at bay

Please ..... no no no.....

The idea of logging on to do the same missions over and over and over again is not my idea of a good time. It is absolutely ridiculous that I can get a quarter million dapper doing an mission for an overseer who will pay more for 6 junk vests than a player can afford to pay for a full set of HA. I don't want a daily routine:

1. Log on do my round of occs.
2. Do my round of overseer missions.
.....

Might as well punch into a job on an assembly line where my job is to stick the same part in the same widget hour after hour every day.

Also the conclusions drawn about pre-merge conditions by peeps who admit they weren't there, let me say this. It took me 4.5 years to collect my NPC plans. These were by no means "abundant". In the course of my time since getting those plans I was able to manage a whopping two crafts of NPC sets.

pre merge i was a silan toon, keep that in mind that i played a toon into the high 40's in all skills but ranged (no ranged weps in silan), there i was a millionare, took me a year to do that there, but that was my choice, everyone told me it's so much simpler to make the dappers on the ML, i go to ML weeks befor merge, no point in making dappers there but did so anyway just to see, it wasn't bad, and my crafted stuff while under q60 always sold well, then we merge, and poof those ok to make dappers are gone, almost nothing i sell get's bought, even when i only mark up 200% i get nothing, pre-merge i could sell crap at 9999% all the time becasue everyone had and could make dappers easy, now it's a joke to get dap's, i'm with freddy, the game's getting too much like a job, i don't mind a little work, but keep it fun and give us options, right now we're locked in to only a very few ways to make good dappers for low lvl toons, guess the ryzom econ is alot like real life, work your A#$ off and get near nothing.

i do agree that i hate logging on to do the dapper mission but the system is broken, you have to currently go out of your way from normal play to make that quarter million, and you have to craft at a high level to do it comfortably im hoping to see some alternatives

i havent done a mission in days and it feels very nice to not do them but eventually i will hit zero again and have to do some, there's really no way around it when npc-selling is 27 dappers a piece and q130 missions are 118k

dappers are now a chore, an aside, an annoyance, for me personally but i havent been able to break all my 1k hawker tools so i dont need that many, after meks and apt, just for tp money and some minor shopping if break a jool or ten.

1 day every week or two weeks i go crazy tping around doing dapper missions then stop for week or two weeks, that has been my routine

I find the new economy to be pretty much just a re-hash of the old.. and I don't think there will be a solution possible. Those that want to accumulate millions of dappers will find a way to do so, no matter how things are re-tooled.

One advantage of the craft missions is that they boost your civilization fame at the same time.

One notable lack in the system (which has always been there to my knowledge), is that there are only rewards now for people that craft armor, melee weapons, jewels, shields or armor.

As primarily an amp crafter, there's a complete lack of reward for pursuing that craft, which should be addressed if this the intended way to work both our craft levels and our bank accounts.

As others have mentioned, there is a lack of reward in missions for those who primarily hunt or fight bandits, etc.

The sergeants/corporals pay substantially better, and I can manage to make about 600K in a few hours of play doing those in a few zones as well, so the economy is exactly the same for high levels..

Sad that I have to reply to myself to enter a few more characters (heh).

Bottom line however is that the economy ends up being about the same as it was 3 years ago. Level up and you will be able to accumulate funds to donate to new players, or help your guildmates out with, etc.

I don't see any change really worth pursuing to 'fix' what is not really the biggest problem in the first place..

I'd rather see future development focused on things that would improve the experience of the game - how about fixing Knoll of Dissent? It's been 'broken' for at least 7 years now, spells still are all area of effect spells there, and I'm sure there's no logical reason for why that should be (none was ever given in lore as to why that would be, nor is the region special in any other way that should make this the case). Now that we have a larger player base under one server, why not open up a few of the other outposts, or some in the Prime Roots? Or implement spires?

+1 Minou, Esp. about lack of missions for amp crafters. I also think there should be better missions for hunters, or those who dont like to do crafting.
Not sure which KoD you were refering to, or what particularly. Do you mean Hidden Source? Or Nexus? Or the KoD in the Jungle?

It is knoll of dissent, where offensive magic has AoE effect. Often annoyed some mektoubs when hitting torbaks.

What puzzles me about the hunters' complaints: I am making a good 30-100k dappers extra income by looting the mobs annoying me on my normal ways (never did b4 the fusion) and place the mat in the merchants at 1000-2000% meaning sthg between 200 and 700 per mat. That stuff is all resold almost immediately.

There is no way to yield mat faster than hunting. Complaints that this mat is only 17dap/mat when sold to merchant are strange. That may easily be 170-400 when put on resale.

I somewhat understand the rants. But guys, the world is as it is. The hardest thing for me was losing all my occupations' skills. Regaining them indeed created a daily chore. But so what?