Azazoar --
In RP terms one does not give up one's holdings without a fight. Even in game terms there is a certain status in owning an OP (Not to mention the fact that even a q50 post occasionally generates q150 mats).
The point that Kimmerin brings up is one of harassment using the game mechanisms and using the letter of the CoC rather than the spirit of the CoC to avoid being slapped down by the PTB.
The problem I see with the proposed solutions is that they represent the possibility of harassment in the opposite direction. Guild A declares on Psykopla Knoll (q50). They bring 3 people since Guild B (who currently owns it) only has 3 active members. Since Guild A is Kami, the Kara Alliance (or whatever) brings 30, beats Guild A's team into a pulp and then reports Guild A for harassment.
I've proposed variants of Naema's solution for making all OPs valuable, but that's not the point of this thread.
In RP terms one does not give up one's holdings without a fight. Even in game terms there is a certain status in owning an OP (Not to mention the fact that even a q50 post occasionally generates q150 mats).
The point that Kimmerin brings up is one of harassment using the game mechanisms and using the letter of the CoC rather than the spirit of the CoC to avoid being slapped down by the PTB.
The problem I see with the proposed solutions is that they represent the possibility of harassment in the opposite direction. Guild A declares on Psykopla Knoll (q50). They bring 3 people since Guild B (who currently owns it) only has 3 active members. Since Guild A is Kami, the Kara Alliance (or whatever) brings 30, beats Guild A's team into a pulp and then reports Guild A for harassment.
I've proposed variants of Naema's solution for making all OPs valuable, but that's not the point of this thread.
---
Remembering Tyneetryk
Phaedreas Tears - 15 years old and first(*) of true neutral guilds in Atys.
(*) This statement is contested, but we are certainly the longest lasting.
<clowns | me & you | jokers>