Mjollren (atys)
Somewhat of a side-note, but I always found it funny that a nation-aligned guild can have members with high personal fame with the enemy nation.. e.g. a matis guild having an Atys Citizen (+50 with fyros while the guild cap is 0).
Astarth -- if spies are indeed to be allowed, then I demand again to be able to join karavan guilds with a kami-aligned char.
and i'd love if that were possible, however game mechanichs doesnt allow it (without using alts which is what some players do anyway)
then there's the problem of rangers never getting implemented, and sadly marauders do provide for a sort of neutral alignment (-45) while having tps... and ofc there are some who aren't even interested in RP, whose only concern is the afore mentioned (and some don't even engage in pvp anyway)
and regardless of what you ask, this is ryzom and don't see the implementation of any of your ideas in the nearby future, so there's not really an stop for the situation.
huggles