Gkr, thanks for stating clearly what Daomei actually complains about. I believe we should now ask you if you have read the previous postings in this thread and ask you to please provide some good arguments why the loot should be distributed in the way you suggest?
What do you make of a team of ten master healers that never did any damage to a boss, but ensured the whole battle wasn't lost? According to your distribution strategy they'd never get any loot _unless_ they join the same guild that does the big damage.
Now why would you restrict roleplaying (neutral players, small guilds all might have a good RP reason to not join a big guild) for the sake of distribution rights?
That's what's a "society" is about: Thinking a bit about others from time to time...
What do you make of a team of ten master healers that never did any damage to a boss, but ensured the whole battle wasn't lost? According to your distribution strategy they'd never get any loot _unless_ they join the same guild that does the big damage.
Now why would you restrict roleplaying (neutral players, small guilds all might have a good RP reason to not join a big guild) for the sake of distribution rights?
That's what's a "society" is about: Thinking a bit about others from time to time...