As I read it he either wants Silan to be turned into an open ganking zone, or create a new ganking realm consisting solely of Silan.
Either is a bad idea. As you said, people'd either quit instantly when confronted with a ganking zone as the start zone, or they'd quit when leaving it and finding the rest of the world isn't a ganking zone.
And for the small number who'd like to be in a ganking zone on a server consisting only of a ganking Silan, the cost of hosting a separate server would be prohitibive.
It's already possible to open yourself to gankers, just go into the arena and wait for someone to arrive and start hacking away at you.
Either is a bad idea. As you said, people'd either quit instantly when confronted with a ganking zone as the start zone, or they'd quit when leaving it and finding the rest of the world isn't a ganking zone.
And for the small number who'd like to be in a ganking zone on a server consisting only of a ganking Silan, the cost of hosting a separate server would be prohitibive.
It's already possible to open yourself to gankers, just go into the arena and wait for someone to arrive and start hacking away at you.