Give gL's a stat boost - IDEAS FOR RYZOM

#1 Added by Cyndalia 10 years ago [en]

Theres only a limited # of GL's and they do tons of extra work whether it be teaching or negotiating OP's or whatever. Why not give the GL's an automatic 10% boost to their current stats. Maybe even give the HO's a 5% boost.

This is a way to reward members within a guild that contribute in one way or another. Right now the promotion system only grants access to gh items. Lets make it more prestegious and ceremonious.

Also, to be fair, limit the amount of people that can be HO's relative to the amount of guild members. The more members i na guild, the more HO slots up to a certain point. That way it will control making everyone's alts an HO as well just for OP war purposes. Thanks

-Cyn

Edited 2 times | Last edited by Cyndalia (10 years ago)

#2 Added by Bitttymacod 10 years ago [en]

{translate}

Cyn -- there used to be a limit on the number of HO's per total membership. Many people complained about it. While I can see your desire to have extra stuff for HO's, you also realize the dangers.

In this case I think that simply making it so that the boost is strictly PvE would solve the HO inflation problem without limiting the number of HO's. It would be tricky, but the GL's could be allowed to keep their boosts since there is only one and he/she is expected to be a little more heroic than other homins.

---

Remembering Tyneetryk
Phaedreas Tears - 15 years old and first(*) of true neutral guilds in Atys.
(*) This statement is contested, but we are certainly the longest lasting.
<clowns | me & you | jokers>

#3 Added by Mely 10 years ago [en]

{translate}

How about some kind of registration system controlled by GM's and some kind a way to verify that they are actuall players and not an alt gl from Alt guilds?

---

Mely "The White Serpent"

~ High Officer of The Arcane ~

#4 Added by Virg 10 years ago [en]

{translate}

Would be way to easy to take advantage of this. Although I understand why you want the idea its open to too much abuse- and GMs controlling it would be too much effort. I would rather seem them make camping illegal again and police that (as they gave up on it because it was 'too much effort') than have to police something like this.

---

________________________

Guild Leader of Syndicate
________________________

Facebook
Syndicate's Page (Shuriiken here)
A glimpse into Virg's life
Thug life

I belong to the warrior in whom the old ways have joined the new
NB: Void respawn is where you can find the PVP, also willing to give lessons :)

#5 Added by Cyndalia 10 years ago [en]

{translate}

I think Bitty's idea to make the boost PvE only is a good one. I also understand Virg's hesitation and how it may be abused in the future.

I'd just like the ability to recognize players based on their participation in guild events and such. The GM's put in much effort, especially in active guilds. And many of the HO's spend countless hours nurturing players in one way or another.

Instead of having the GM's workload increased by monitoring alt guilds, having this feature available for subbed account only can reduce the amount of future abuse. After all, many of the Alts (but I realize not all) are on F2P accounts. If people want to sub all their alts to have a slight advantage, that's more income for game development as far as I'm concerned. They'd still have to spend a significant amount of time grinding to master their subbed alts, so it wouldn't be a free giveaway.

#6 Added by Rubiksmomo 10 years ago [en]

{translate}

I wouldn't do it, it would be exploited with 100% certainty. All players without a guild should then form a single player guild to get the boost.

---

I don't want to be the one
The battles always choose
'Cause inside I realize
That I'm the one confused

#7 Added by Irfidel 9 years ago [en]

{translate}

Wouldn't do it either because of two reasons. Firstly I also see the potential of abuse and the amount of work required to prevent it.

Secondly, I know I might be naive and I'm surely idealistic believing that the reward of the guild leaders cannot be paid in stats or items. It's the respect paid by other players in and outside of the guild and well developed friendships within the guild.

Note that there are interesting studies done about the altering behaviour when a reward that used to be a social one (a "thank you", or even just a smile) to a monetary one. There's nothing good about that change. Since i feel that's off topic here, I won't go into details unless requested otherwise.

Let's hope our good guild leaders continue to do their hard work just because it actually provides them with fun in doing so. Thanks to all of you!

#8 Added by Nizyros 9 years ago [fr]

{translate}

Je pense que ce n'est pas nécessaire....

Ce qui peut récompenser un bon GL, c'est les membres et l'évolution des membres de sa guilde. Et je pense que cela suffit largement^^.

Pas besoin de toucher au statistiques qui pourrai créer des inégalités au sein du jeu.

Last edited by Tiximei (9 years ago) | Reason: Fixed language button

---

#9 Added by Remigra 9 years ago [de]

{translate}

ich finde diese Idee nicht gut. wenn der GL 10% boost bekäme, würden plötzlich 200 1 mann Gilden mehr rumlaufen, nur um diesen Bonus zu bekommen.

in einer gut funktionierenden Gilde ist jeder, sei es GL, HO, O oder Member, Voll oder Free Account für die Gilde verantwortlich. und das es funktioniert.

jeder bringt seinen Beitrag so gut wie er es kann. eine Gilde muss auch dann funktionieren, wenn der GL nicht anwesend ist. sicher je höher der rang, je höher die Verantwortung. aber diese hat man sich ja letztendlich selbst ausgesucht oder gewünscht.

wenn ich eine Gilde gründe, ist das freiwillig, und wenn ich nur spielen will und kaum Verantwortung, dann gründe ich so etwas nicht.
im Endeffekt ist die grösste Belohnung für einen GL wenn seine Gilde auch dann funktioniert, wenn teile dieser, die wichtige Positionen haben fehlen, und sie dennoch funktioniert.

eine HO Begrenzung auf die Member-zahl, würde wiederum viele twinks und nicht gespielte chars in die Gilden treiben.

frei nach dem Motto, oh... ich brauche einen HO platz mehr, also leg ich mal eben noch einen Free Account an, ich hab ja erst 10 @_@ -hust-

die Begrenzung ist für klein-Gilden, ein Problem. diese haben so kaum die Möglichkeit ganz-zeitlich ihren Member Zugang auf die GH Inhalte zu gewähren.

Es wurden Gilden-titel eingeführt, die man sich an den kopf hängen kann ^^. eine nette Idee. aber wohl nicht genug :)

Belohnungen, die keine vorteile bringen anderen gegenüber (also ehr als Statussymbole) fände ich ok, alles andere wäre kein Gleichgewicht.

Jeder sucht sich seinen weg hier selber aus, das macht das spiel so real. alles kann nichts muss. und wenn man sich den weg eines GL ausgesucht hat, oder die Position eines HO annimmt, dann sollte einem sowieso bewusst sein was er für Verantwortung trägt. wenn nicht sollte er es sein lassen ;)

meine Meinung.

---

"Decateis I Kamirac" "Necateis Sye Mideshye"
"Decateis I Loke" "Necateis Atys Morhdeis"
"I Nidran Sye Alede E Sye Neyde Ilya Necateis I Ulca"

"Liberi I`Margus"

_ Graphic-Team _

#10 Added by Gidget 9 years ago [en]

{translate}

I'm just wondering how long it would take before someone started abusing it. My thoughts are that if they did it at a dead hour on a weekday it might go without exploitation for an hour, possibly two, but that's about it. And I am pretty sure that someone would find a more creative way to take advantage of it than has been brought up in this thread thusfar.

---

Do not assume that you speak for all just because you are the loudest voice; there are many who disagree that simply have no desire to waste words on you.