First, I appreciate how much thought you've put into this idea, and how passionate you seem to be about it. I read it carefully, and agree you have some good points. However, I still disagree.
I do not believe that the forums we all share are the place for heated personal arguments, any more than the supermarket or classroom is, and even the manager of the supermarket has enough sense to ask you to leave, rather than let you disturb all of his other previously happy customers further.
Disputes, and anger, encourage more disputes and anger. Better to close the wound, clean it, and be done with it. Such arguments can be had elsewhere, if they are truly necessary.
I do not believe that the forums we all share are the place for heated personal arguments, any more than the supermarket or classroom is, and even the manager of the supermarket has enough sense to ask you to leave, rather than let you disturb all of his other previously happy customers further.
Disputes, and anger, encourage more disputes and anger. Better to close the wound, clean it, and be done with it. Such arguments can be had elsewhere, if they are truly necessary.